In the dynamic world of project management, we often find ourselves navigating the tricky terrain of project indicators, where projects can sometimes resemble traffic lights. We may perceive them as green, amber, or red, but the reality may not always match our perception. This phenomenon is aptly described as “subjective traffic lighting,” where trust in project statuses can lead to surprises down the road. In this article, we’ll dive into a fascinating concept in project management – the ‘Watermelon Project.’ We’ll explore what it is, why it occurs, and how to prevent it from turning your project into a ‘red’ disaster camouflaged as ‘green.’

Understanding Watermelon Projects:

Imagine a watermelon on a hot summer day – its green exterior glistening in the sun, promising a refreshing treat. But what if, when you slice it open, you discover that it’s not juicy and ripe on the inside, but instead, it’s pale and disappointing? In project management, a ‘Watermelon Project’ is akin to this misrepresentation. It appears ‘Green’ on the outside, signifying smooth progress, but hides ‘Red’ within, concealing underlying issues that could jeopardize the project’s success.

Why Watermelon Projects Occur:

  • Miscommunication and Subjective Assessment: Watermelon projects often result from miscommunication within project teams and subjective assessments. Team members may trust the ‘Green’ status given by a project leader, assuming that everything is on track when, in fact, key indicators are signaling trouble.
  • Over-Optimism: Project managers or stakeholders may sometimes be overly optimistic, hoping to present a positive image to superiors or clients. This over-optimism can lead to a misrepresentation of the project’s true status.
  • Failure to Address Risks: Ignoring potential risks or issues within a project can be a common precursor to the watermelon effect. When risks are downplayed or overlooked, they can fester and turn a project ‘Red’ without warning.

Detecting and Preventing Watermelon Projects:

  • Objective Metrics: Rely on objective metrics and data to assess the true project status. Implement key performance indicators (KPIs) that provide an unbiased view of progress.
  • Regular Communication: Foster a culture of open communication within your project team. Encourage team members to voice concerns, ask questions, and provide honest feedback.
  • Risk Management: Identify and address potential risks early in the project lifecycle. Develop mitigation strategies to prevent issues from escalating.
  • Transparent Reporting: Present project status transparently to all stakeholders. Avoid glossing over problems to maintain an image of ‘Green’ when it’s not warranted.

Kiwi Projects: The Ideal Scenario:

On the brighter side of project management, there are ‘Kiwi Projects.’ These projects are not just ‘Green’ on the outside, but they’re also ‘Green’ on the inside. They represent the perfect blend of effective communication, risk management, and transparent reporting. Kiwi projects are a testament to a well-executed project management process.


Watermelon projects can be misleading and potentially harmful to project outcomes. To prevent falling victim to this illusion, it’s essential to employ objective metrics, foster transparent communication, and proactively manage risks. By doing so, your projects can transform from potentially ‘Red’ watermelons into thriving ‘Kiwi Projects,’ where the ‘Green’ status accurately reflects the true state of affairs. In the world of project management, a little skepticism can go a long way in ensuring project success, making sure that what appears green on the outside is indeed green throughout.

Want to find out more about how AMO can help with your project management capability? Have a look here ( how our team can help yours reach their full project management potential. If you want to know more, contact us on